If the melody has also an underlying chord progression then there is an alternative way to find the centers of the melody as in the post 118.
In a triad or 4-notes with 7 nth chord , the most characteristic notes are the middle 2nd note (in 1-3-5 interval notation is the 3) and the 7 nth (if it exists) as the define their character as minor-major and 7nth or extended in general. Therefore these two notes have higher probability to be the notes of the simplicial submelody. In general in a chord transition X-->Y , the notes of simplical sub-melody can be one starting note from X and and ending note in Y.
The themes of a melody consist of a plot or sequence of the 4 basic moves (see post 59) which by itself says an emotional story without the help of the harmony. If we have (as here we assume we do) an underlying chord progression, then utilizing almost all the notes of the chords and one theme for each of the 3-harmonic-types of chord transitions , we may define the set of themes of the melody in easy way. Alternatively we may define a theme for each type of emotion, sad, joy, anxiety or serenity, or a theme for each type of chord respectively minor (sad) major (happy), 7nth or diminished or augmented (anxiety) and r5 (serenity.) The chord progression serves as a way to transform and make variations of the themes. The notes of the simplicial submelody may be the centers of the melody that sound longer and are usually the tops and bottoms of the 4 basic melodic moves that create the themes of the melody but also the notes of the underlying chord.
The next video in jazz improvisation music shows that in fact any of the 12 notes of the chromatic scale and not only the 3 or 4 notes of the chord can be chosen as the note of the simplicial sub-melody during a chord!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IzWEyHTu_Zc
Another more practical way of course as we have mentioned in other posts (see e,g. post 72) is defining the simplicial sub-melody through the stating and ending points of the melodic themes.
1) Chromatic simplicial sub-melody. A second a but more sophisticated way is to do exactly the same except that the 1st voice is defined not by the highest note in the chords but through the simplicial submelody. The simplicual submelody is defined by the next rules.
1.1) When two successive chords of the chord progression have notes that are one semitone distance only, we chose these two notes as notes of the simplicial sub-melody. For reasons of flexibility we allow two notes per chord if necessary. This happens for all cases that the two consecutive chords in a diatonic scale that are at roots distance of an interval of pure 4th (5 semitones) or pure 5th (7 semitones) or if they are mutually complementary chords (with roots of one step of the scale apart). In general it is a good idea to chose as notes of the simplicial submelody for two successive chords in the chord progression, two notes, one from each chord with the minimum distance in semitones from the notes of the two chords. And alternatively for a 2nd voice we may take the 2 notes in the chords respectively with the maximum distance between them for maximum action of waving movements! This in general may lead to two notes per chord in the chord progression, the second note is reserved for the 2nd voice etc. The more correct rule to find the simplicial submelody is as few notes per chord as possible that give the basic feeling of the melody.
1.2) If the two consecutive chords are mutually relative with two common notes, the notes of the simplicial submelody for each chord are either a common note or the note that the other chord does not contain!
1.3) Chromatic links simplicial submelody (also bass lines) In general we may have the next rule. If X1, X2 are two succesive chords of the chord progression, and we are at X1, a chromatic ling or chromatic bridge is defined by finding two notes a1 in X1, a2 in X2, so taht a1-a2 is at the minimum interval distance among all other chord notes. Then the chromatic link starts with a1, b1,b2....,bn,a2 , and with a2 and all the intermediate steps are one semitone distance.
1.4) Minimal chromatic drone sub-melody (MCD sub-melody).
This simplicial sub-melody is like the chromatic sub-melody, except that we utilize preferably the common notes of the chords, and we require it
1.4.1) of as few notes as possible and
1.4.2) of as little distance as possible.
The rules are the next
Rule 1: We start from the chord and we find a common note with its next chord. If there are two common notes, we look at the next 3rd chord and chose this that is also either a note of the 3rd--next chord or minimal distance of a note of it. We proceed in this way till the last chord of the underlying chord progression.
It can be proved that if the chord progression are chords of a diatonic scale, then the minimal chromatic drone melody, can have only some or all of the first 3 notes of the scale (e.g. in a C major mode diatonic scale the c, d, e)
A minimal chromatic drone sub-melody need not be a kind of bass-line! It very well be a kind of very high register or octave simple melodic line. Personally I prefer the latter.
2) Harmonic simplicial sub-melody. Probably the best method of creating the simplicial sub-melody which is based on preferring intervals distances of the notes of the simplicial sub-melody (opposite to the previous method) that are large intervals ,namely intervals of 5ths , 4th 6th or 8th. . The simplicial sub-melody is somehow the centers or oscilaltion boundaries of the final melody and most often it is one note per chord of the chord progression . It can also be considered as a very simple bass line parallel to the melody. So the rule to choose the simplicial sub-melody is the next
3.1) If we have two successive chords X(1) -> X(2) in the chord progression, and a is the note of the simplicial sub-melody belonging to chord X(1) , and b is the not of the simplicial sub-melody belonging to the chord X(2), then a->b is an interval in the following order of preference 5th, 4th, 8th, 6th.
If the X(1) -> X(2) are in the relation of resolution (succesive in the wheel by 4ths) e.g. G->C then we have 3 choices for a->b, the g->c, or b->e, or d->g. If the X(1) -> X(2) are in the relation of relative chords (two common notes) e.g. C->Em then we have 2 choices for a->b,
c->g, or e->b. And if the X(1) -> X(2) are in the chromatic or complementary relation of chords (roots that differ by one step of the scale) e.g. C->Dm, then we have one only choice or a->b, here the c->f. After we have defined the simplicial sub-melody then we create bridges between its notes by smaller intervals e.g. 3rds or 2nds.
3) Default simplicial sub-melody. This is simply the melody created by the roots of the chords of the chord progression.
We have mentioned in this post that the simplicial submelody is usually the starting or ending notes of simple melodic themes, that can be external bridges of the chord transitions (of density diatonic or middle harmonic etc). Therefore here we apply the 3 basic transformations and starting from a single melodic theme ending to the first note of the simplicial submelody we translate or invert or vary rhythmically thsi theme, and make it end (or start) on the next note of the simplicial submelody. The transformed melodic themes derived in this way cover most often two chords or a chord transition or chord relation
Still another important remark is that we may have HIGHER ORDER SIMPLICIAL SUBMELODIES. In other words except the 1st simplification ofthe melody, which is the 1st order simplicial submelody, we may have the 2nd order simplicial submelody, the 3rd order simplicial submelody, each one simpler that its previous. A path from the complexity to simplicity. One of them should correspond of course to the complexity of the chord-progresion, that is have one note for each chord of the chord progression.
The starting and ending notes of the melodic themes may define a simplicial submelody, while the centers of the melody a higher order simplicial submelody.
The 3 elementary melodic themes, as we mentioned earlier (e.g. in posts 66 and 69 ) , are the ascending melodic interval of two notes, the isokratic melodic interval of two equal notes and the descending melodic interval of two notes.
1) the translation (either with intervals of 2nd , (or diatonic density) or intervals of 3rd (or middle harmonic density) or of intervals of 4th or 5th (or high harmonic density))
2) The inversion where the ascending move becomes descending.
3) Rhythm transformation (which may vary)
The 5 basic melodic moves (see e.g. post 69) , being more complicated have more types of transformations, as derived by the writing in a pentagram :
1) Translation
Bach has often used the above 6 transformations in his fugue.
We give an example of the simplicial sub-melody with the next melody of folk music with Cuatro https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ob50UXyr1JE
1) WHICH CHORD-TRANSITIONS (PAIRS OF CHORDS) WILL HAVE A MELODIC BRIDGE! (Usually the chord-trasnitions that are in resolutional relation, or resolutional-like relation)
3) THEN IF IN EACH EQUIVALENCE CLASS OF ISOMORPHIC MELODIC BRIDGES IN THIS PARTITIONING, THE BRIDGES ARE EVENTUALLY ASCENDING OR DESCENDING (This besides the emotional significance, determines also where to play the chord in one of the 3 neighborhoods of the fretboard)
4) FINALLY HOW IN EACH EQUIVALENCE CLASS OF ISOMORPHIC MELODIC BRIDGES IN THE PARTITIONING, THE COMPLICATED PITCH DYNAMIC SHAPE OR WAVING AND RHYTHM WILL BE AS A REPETITION OF SUCH PATTERNS OF PREVIOUS ISOMORPHIC MELODIC BRIDGES, OR VARIATION OF SUCH PATTERNAS S SO NOT TO BE TOO BORING. (This pitch dynamic shape has again a significant emotional meaning)
5) THE JUSTIFICATION OF THE CHORD PROGRESSION USUALLY IS NOT DONE BY THE CHOICE OF THE MELODIC BRIDGES (THAT IS GIVEN THE MELODIC BRIDGES MAYBE A SIMPLER CHORD PROGRESSION MAY COVER THEM HARMONICALLY). BUT AN INTERMEDIATE HARPING OR STRUMMING OF EACH CHORD WILL ENHANCE THE MELODY OF THE BRIDGES SO THAT ONLY THIS CHORD PROGRESSION IS JUSTIFIED!
DEFAULT MELODIES FOR A CHORD PROGRESSION.
Given a chord progression it is direct how to create a melody that fits the chords, with the following rules
1) During each chord, the entry note of the simplicial submelody , is the middle note of the chord.
2) During each chord, the exit note of the simplicial submelody (two notes per chord here), for major chords (including 7nth chords and extensions) is the upper note of the chord, for minor, diminished and augmented chords it is the lower note of the chord.
3) During the chord the melody follows an harmonic theme in one or more octaves span, in other words from notes of the chords, and is walking the chord by a spike, straight scaling or waving (these are parameters for the composer or improviser to choose) from middle and down to up (joy) if the chord is major, or from middle and upper to down (sadness) if it is minor, diminished or augmented. Alternatively any descending , ascending or waving sequence of notes at diatonic speed such that the odd or even number of them is exactly the notes of the chord (extended probably by 7nth or 6th) and these motes sound e.g. 3 times more than the notes of the rest of the scaling is a melody that fits the particular chord! Irish melodies do it often. If the chord is simply major or minor we may enhance its harmony by extending it with its upper and lower relatives thus by an interval of 3rd at the highest note and up , or at the lowest note and lower (in normal position). In other words making it a chord with 6th and/or 7nth.
An interesting case of simplicial submelody is the first choice always (interval of 5th or 4th).
Still another case is the minimal harmonic simplicial submelody (but always with notes of the chords) where we take always the 2nd choice (the x1-x2 interval of 3rd, or x1-x4 interval of 7th) where this sounds 2/3 of the time and 1/3 of the time the 3rd note of the chord. This simplicial submelody gives emphasis to the character of each chord, that is being minor , major or 7th etc.
This simplicial submelody can be the centers of full melody over this chord progression
Then the chord X7 has only one note x1 for simplicial submelody the starting note of the melodic move, and the end note x2 of the melodic move is the next simlicial submelody note and one note of the chord x+1 not common with the chord X7. If the latter note x2 is not the root of x+1, it is created a tension that has to be resolved later where x2 would be the root of x+1. The tension is highest if the x2 is the 3rd note, middle of it is the 2nd note and resolving if it is the root note. In between the x1 and x2, the rule is that at least 2/3 of the notes belong to the underlying chord, and this can be achieved by repeating notes of the underlying chord if necessary. The move x1->x2 may involve each of the chords X7, x+1 , twice in two octaves each instead of once in one octave only, which may create very impressive melodic effects. This gives an even better opportunity to use in the melodic move, intervals of 8th, 4th and 5th (high harmonic speed, see post 68) , that have higher harmonic score than the other intervals (see post 40). The at most 1/3 of the total duration of the move x1->x2 ,of notes that play with underlying the 1st chord but may be outside the starting chord, might be unusually at chromatic and diatonic speed (see post 68), and sometimes might belong to the next chord or even to none of the two chords. The chromatic or diatonic speed applies usually when approaching the ending note of the melodic move. The melodic moves x1-->x2 can be called chord-transition melodic moves and must have an element of repetition in length and rhythm. In the transitional Irish melodies that utilize 2-3 only major chords, while the melodic moves are 4-5 or 6-7 , but also in the traditional Greek music of the Aegean Islands, the starting and ending point of the melodic move is during the duration of a single chord and are notes of the chord! But still the rule 2/3 -1/3 for notes internal and external to the chord still holds, and the starting and ending notes of the melodic move may define the simplicial submelody.
6) The harmonic move lasts longer than the transitional dense (chromatic or diatonic harmonic speed) melodic move , as the latter takes less than 30% of the duration of x, and y.
7) From the rule of local fitness of a melody to a chord progression , such a default melody will fit the chord progression.
Here is the result.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CEPsAIqnVao
(This post has not been written completely yet)